Sunday, April 29, 2012

Startup Weekends and What Educators Must Learn

This weekend as part of my ongoing self-directed inquiry on developing an education system more appropriate for our times, I attended the open portion of  Start-Up Weekend Hamilton.  Startup Weekends put teams of people through the entire collaborative project process in three days. We've all heard of how Google, Apple, MediaLab and IdeaLab work. We know about the relaxed work environments, the free flow of communication and ideas, the buzz, the collaboration, problem-solving, risk-taking, learning from trial and error, ....  We also know that we need to foster collaborative problem solving skills in our students.  I have done a great deal of experimentation with project-based learning and inquiry, but what I really wanted to see was what it looked like in action among people who consistently work in this way.

The process at Startup Weekends is simple:

1. Identify a real problem.
2. Work with your team to devise a solution.
3. Conduct research and seek feedback throughout the process.
4. Develop an application.
4. Present this solution in less than 5 minutes at the end of the weekend.
5. Receive real and meaningful feedback.+
At StartUps the projects are real; the goal is to obtain investor funding and launch an application.

What did I learn?

A great deal.

I realized that although this is the model we are expected to use with our students, most of us have never truly seen it in action.  It gets more unsettling - most of us have never experienced true collaborative learning. We grew up in teacher-directed classrooms; we teach in directed classrooms. We attempt to practice collaborative inquiry, but we don't quite hit the mark.  Even more unsettling, our students who need to be learning these skills, aren't! While I sat and observed and finally understood, I really wished that more educators were in the room with me.

What to do? Practice needs to shift and we can't wait 10 years. It has to happen now. The new economy demands it.  Singularity U comes to mind.  Singularity U brings together diverse minds in order to accelerate the spread of knowledge and the process of change exponentially.  I think this would be a good model for education. In order to rapidly expand understanding of true collaborative inquiry teachers should be put through a StartUp Weekend experience.  Other than being an enormous amount of fun, once teachers have had the experience of collaborative inquiry, it will become easy to implement. I really think the solution is that simple.

Knowing that we can't afford to wait, I connected with Blake Landry of NGen http://ngen-niagara.com/en/content/welcome/index/  Blake and I discussed creating a Startup experience for learners in our schools.  Ideally, it would be a format where educators and learners came together to experience collaborative project-based learning. So that is what is in the works.








  

Friday, April 27, 2012

Good-Bye Mike Harris!

On Thursday April 26, 2012 I took 4 students to present at the OPSAO conference at the Sutton Place Hotel in Toronto. OPSOA is The Ontario Public Supervisory Official's Association. It is made up of Directors of Education from school boards across Ontario as well as Superintendents. The theme this year was "Inspire, Improve, Innovate and Integrate". Sessions focused on bringing innovation and creativity into our school systems.

Our delegation from the HWDSB included John Laverty, Superintendent, Jenn George our former VP at Dundas Central, Audrey Henson, our current VP and former Literacy Improvement Teacher, Barry Morlog our current Principal, myself and 4 students.

Side note: The commuter train was late and we had to race through Union Station to the subway and from the subway to the hotel.  The event was already underway as we made a grand and noisy entrance in a "Here come the rumpled teachers on a school trip," kind of a way. Disrupting education indeed!

It was very exciting for us to be invited to participate in this conference. Classroom teachers and students typically have very little contact with decision makers in our school systems. Because of the national and international recognition my students and I have received, we've found ourselves in a rather unique position.  We have a voice. We've bridged the communication barrier and those "above" are listening.

In bridging that communication barrier, I have to say that what I found was not what I expected. For the first time I was able to see my place as a classroom teacher within a broader system. Teachers don't typically see themselves as part of an educational ecosystem; we tend to think in terms of our place within the limited boundaries of our schools.  After my experience yesterday I see this as a problem. By not seeing one's place within a system, one is left with a sense of  unintended powerlessness. This is the Ontario Leadership Framework for education. It is important that teachers claim their professionalism and see their place within it.

The delegation from our board was organized by John Laverty and the purpose was to share how each level in our board is working towards a common goal.  This can't be understood without mentioning our fabulous new Director, John Malloy.  Under John's direction  the HWDSB has undergone a tremendous cultural shift.  In very simple terms it can  be summed up as what John stopped and what he started.

John stopped the initiative upon initiative madness where we were constantly subjected to the latest educational bandwagon, where nothing was ever dropped and where we never had a chance to fully implement anything before the next program wave hit.

Instead he developed a 5 year strategic plan in conjunction with schools in which achievement, equity and engagement matter. Any programs or initiatives that did not fit under that umbrella were eliminated. He also shifted the leadership culture within the board; administrators began  using a different vocabulary when working with staff.  Teacher training became centered on effective practices and high yield strategies.  Every level within the board was expected to work within this framework. All of this was experimental - we were asked to do things that we didn't fully understand, and there was a great deal of resistance initially. We had no idea that we were developing a new model of education for the province of Ontario. (Note to self: read the documents!)

What John is doing is capacity building:


Capacity building is a conceptual approach to development that focuses on understanding the obstacles that inhibit people, governments, international organizations and non-governmental organizations from realizing their developmental goals while enhancing the abilities that will allow them to achieve measurable and sustainable results


The Ministry of Education for the province of Ontario is committed to the process and this the reason why Ontario is so highly regarded internationally.  The Ministry is bringing about system change.  http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/literacynumeracy/inspire/research/capacityBuilding.html

The process has not always run smoothly. Teachers were resistant initially and there was a great sense of confusion, fear and of being judged as we were asked to change our practices.  Administrators fumbled and at times were awkward in guiding us as they too learned how to lead in a different way. I think many of us interpreted the message as "you are inadequate" rather than the non-judgemental "research shows that what we are asking you to do will make learning better for children" that was intended. No matter how much we questioned and resisted, the expectation to make changes and align our practices with the strategic plan remained. For a while we felt very micromanaged and that was difficult. For a while our practice became very narrow and extremely teacher directed which killed student engagement.  Eventually, though, we began to understand and appreciate the changes because of the impact they were having on learners.

What I learned at OPSOA was how every level within our board fits into the process. John Laverty explained his role as Superintendent, Jen explained her role as school admin, Audrey explained her role as LIPT, I explained my role as teacher, and the students shared their experience of learning in ways more appropriate for the 21st century.  I am grateful to have had this opportunity. If it hadn't been for the conference, we would never have taken time to consider the larger story of our board and what we've accomplished to date.  What I recognized at OPSOA is that the role of administrators has changed and they are there to support what we are trying to accomplish in our classrooms. I left with an exceptional level of respect for our Director and what he is attempting to achieve.

I also realized it was time to let go of the Mike Harris years scars and embrace what education in our province is becoming.  I was thrilled that the topics of conversation were about innovation and creativity and student engagement. It was a relief to know that even though most of the people at the conference are not involved in the global conversation occurring through social media (seriously, there was not even a hashtag for the conference),  the concerns and topics of discussion are the same. More importantly, these leaders are ready to embrace a new model for student engagement.

Which brings me to my students. We showed our Mind Share Learning Video and then each student had two minutes to share openly and honestly their experiences of being globally connected learners. Ryan G, Dexter C, Bianca K and Taylor B  - you were outstanding!  Your voices were heard and you at your young age have directly affected policy and decision making in the province of Ontario. Many people came up afterwards to share how inspired they were by your words.

I know that this experience had a tremendous impact on my students. For the first time they saw their place and contribution within a larger framework. I have no desire to put words in their mouths. I will let them process their thoughts and then perhaps do a podcast interview so they can share their insights.

I also have a second post to write about a conversation I had with John Malloy after our presentation at OPSOA. We discussed that we are only at the beginning of the transformation that needs to occur and that he has a problem and needs help solving it. More to follow ...





















Wednesday, April 25, 2012

We're Taking the Train!

Tomorrow I will be taking a small group of students to Toronto to speak at the annual OPSOA conference. It is our opportunity to share with the Minister and Directors of Education as well as Superintendents from across Ontario what it is like to be involved in innovative learning experiences at school. This is very exciting for all of us. The most common comment from all of these students as they wrote their speeches was that when they are engaged in this type of learning it doesn't feel like they are stuck in a classroom. Hm. 

Monday, April 23, 2012

What the US Can't Learn From Finland

If you've been following the dreadful education battle that has been underway in the US for the past few years, you'll know that the Finland model has been suggested as a solution to their woes. A Finnish educator has written a powerful post in response to this suggestion. What the US Can't Learn From Finland:
http://www.pasisahlberg.com/blog/?p=84




Maps, Critical Thinking and Good-bye to the Lecture

Let me begin by saying I still believe that there is a place for the lecture method in a teacher's repertoire.

In grade 7 we are currently studying New France and the fall of Quebec.  In the past, I would have taught well-planned lessons that told the story of the British conquest,  the various battles blah, blah, blah.
Today we did not do that. Instead we engaged in a critical thinking activity where students were given maps and asked to draw conclusions.



Students self-organized into small groups and I gave them questions to think about. These included:

1. Why is the first map a logical way to show boundaries for First Nations peoples.
2. For there to have been a treaty, what must have happened?
3. If France no longer controlled New France after 1763, why are there still French people living in Canada today?

All students were able to figure out that a war must have occurred and the French must have lost. They also predicted that land may have been sold.  And they concluded that the British had allowed the French to remain on their farms.  I did no traditional teaching except at the end when we gathered as a class. We shared conclusions and revisited our original inquiry question: what led to the October Crisis of 1970 and the separatist movement.  Students recognized that the French were a conquered people.

Tomorrow we will view material from a variety of sources to determine whether or not our conclusions are correct. Students didn't have to memorize facts, the lowest level of skill on the Thinking Matrix. Instead, they engaged with facts in order to think critically.

One thing we did not discuss, but will, are missing voices.  This pulls the media literacy piece into social studies. Key concepts: All media are constructed. Media contain idealogical and value messages. Who drew the maps? Whose voice is missing? How would First Nations people have responded to the maps?

I always enjoy watching students shift into inquiry and listening to the discussion that evolves as they begin thinking. They play with possibilities and ideas. They wonder and imagine.  Conversation becomes very natural. I circulate, engage, respond to questions and give prompts to further thinking.

The students loved this approach to learning. We compared it to how I would have taught it in the past. Almost all agreed that this was a more interesting approach and that they were more likely to recall the information because they had figured it out themselves.

Sunday, April 22, 2012

A High Yield Strategy: Peer Feedback

High Yield Strategies: Peer Feeback

This week grade 7 students have been working on very structured writing activities. They have had to write short essays supporting particular points of view based on evidence they have gathered from texts, their background knowledge and from what we have learned in class.  Once the essays were written students were asked to provide feedback to their peers based on Success Criteria that we had developed as a class. Success Criteria include the structural elements or text features as well as thinking. Peer feedback is one of the many High Yield Strategies that Ontario teachers have been trained to use to improve student learning. Teachers in our school have been experimenting and developing systems for this process. 

Below are examples of peer feedback. Students used postit notes to mark points in the essays where they found evidence of the Success Criteria. They are expected to look not just for text features (thesis, evidence etc), but also for thinking - did the writer make inferences, go beyond the most obvious interpretation, include original ideas ...  They were also expected to make suggestions for improvement. Peer feedback improves the writing of  the provider as well as the recipient. Students then meet and go over the feedback with their peers.  

Once this process was finished, I went over their work to make further suggestions for improvement.  Students who were clearly struggling with the process (perhaps 4 or 5 in the class) went to the Resource Teacher for additional instruction for 1 period. I assess the quality of the feedback as well as the essays.







Here a student has pointed out that the facts are incorrect in the essay.








Friday, April 13, 2012

Hooking Them in is an Art Form!

Grade 7 students have been learning about the history of New France. I have used this as an opportunity to focus on developing better note taking skills and practising some of the more structured aspects of writing essential to communicating effectively.
Some of the students - well, ok - all of the students have found the work a little dry. This is not necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes improving foundation skills requires just grinding away at a task in order to make the leap forward.

One of the problems of the New France unit is that it appears to be yet another study of pioneers.  Hooking students into a topic in a compelling way is the art of good teaching. I decided to leave the past and leap forward to 1970 and the October Crisis. We took a day to learn about the FLQ, the kidnappings, the assassination of LaPorte, the suspension of civil rights under the War Measures Act and the referendum where the break up of Canada became a true possibility. And how separatist rumblings are ever present in Canadian politics even today.  Extensive footage from the period is available on You Tube - a fabulous reason to have this tool unblocked. It was eye opening for students to learn that what happens in other countries can also happen here.

Of course, for the students, the question became "Why? Why did this happen?" Now we have returned to our unit with an essential question.  We have a purpose for learning how New France developed and why events of the past are affecting our present. They are hooked.  

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Building Our Minecraft Server

We've begun spending our prize money for the Ken Spencer Award. 10 iPad2's have been ordered and the school has piggy backed onto the exceptional discount Apple is offering to educators right now; 20 more have been ordered thanks to the home and school and teachers purchasing for their classrooms.

My husband who teaches information technology at Humber College has connected us to some of his talented students who are building a dedicated Minecraft server for our club. We will be able to have at least 30 players on at a time. Once again, thank you Ken Spencer!  As I type, they are out purchasing equipment. You can follow the build in real time on twitter @educrafting

There has been intense discussion all week from the students in the club who range from grades 3 to 7.   The discussions have been sophisticated and thoughtful.  They've weighed pros and cons of various design options and are extremely curious about how the server will be structured. They've also identified risk factors and implications of decisions that we might make as a group and have begun to hash out conduct guidelines.  A chief concern is who will have administrative rights for the server. These are extremely knowledgeable and thoughtful students and I appreciate their guidance as I am, once again, the level 2 student in the group (well, if I'm being totally honest, level 1).




Monday, April 9, 2012

A National Vision for 21 Century Education

A number of organizations and institutions have banded together to formulate a vision of what education in Canada should evolve into. It is research-based and pulls together the ideas being promoted globally on how an advanced education system should be structured.  I find it very exciting because this model will bring back student engagement and creativity - aspects that have been pushed out of education in the current aim for high scores in the standardized tests model.

http://www.c21canada.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/C21-Canada-Shifting_Minds.pdf

The question becomes: how do we as a community - students, parents, business leaders, teachers, educational assistants, researchers ... work together to accelerate or be at the forefront of implementation? It's about more than bringing technology into our schools - it's about how learning should be.

Let's be the leaders in development of this model.

Closing Down the NFB - and Other Attacks on Voice

It is puzzling that this story isn't gaining  more traction.  The federal government is closing the NFB - National Film Board - offices in Montreal and Toronto. Sigh. As an educator who relies regularly on the NFB in my program, I shake my head.  As a citizen who understands the importance of culture to survival of any civilization, I despair.  As an educator who understands that jobs of the future will rely on the ability to use and produce digital media I shudder at the shortsightedness. As a tax-payer who recognizes the economic engine that the film industry represents, I think .. what the ...?

As an observer of government I can't help but make connections.  It's about the power of voice. No government likes to provide funding to organizations that produce critical thinkers who are capable of challenging ideas.  It makes governing messy and difficult.  It is so much easier to govern when the citizenry remains uninformed.  If the documentary makers don't have the funding to document with a critical eye

Friday, April 6, 2012

It's Time to Let Teachers Be Part of the Conversation

This week I was invited to bring one of my students to The Ministry of Education's regional SIM (Schools in the Middle) meeting to participate on a student panel.  The purpose of the panel was to bring student voice into discussions on education.  These grades 5 and 6 students were outstanding as they shared their insights.  Our Dundas Central representative was articulate and thoughtful in her responses. I was so proud of her. She distinguished herself on that panel.

I was invited to come back for the second day without my student to participate in discussions. The group is made up (as far as I could tell) of various people from the Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat and 8-10 school boards from the region whose participants were primarily cluster principals, consultants and lead teachers.

My two primary reactions to this event? Relief and respect.

For the first time I was allowed to peer through the window into how administrators have experienced the broad system change that our province has gone through. And you know what?  All of the struggles, questions, frustrations, concerns, confusions, and uncertainties that we've experienced as classroom teachers going through this process, they too have experienced. It was such a relief to know this.  It would have been so much easier to go through this process of change had those at the system level simply acknowledged that they too have found it to be challenging, that they too were doing this as trial and error and learning as they went, that they didn't have all the answers.

A seat at the table made me aware of just how broad the redesign of our school system has been. There actually has been a vision of what our schools would become based on solid research of what makes an effective learning environment. It also made me aware that the process has been as messy and experimental for administrators as it has been for us. Each board and school is taking the ideas of effective practice and developing their own methods of implementation.  Everyone has been working on construction sites, learning from failures and successes along the way.

Some really exciting and interesting discussions occurred over the two days.  There were skyped presentations from various schools and boards who shared success stories, practices and awareness that this is being done by experimentation and refinement of process as learning occurs. There was an Open Space session where we brought our questions and engaged in meaningful discussion. We sat at cross board tables and shared practices.  I learned so much and my respect for the process, the administrators and the vision grew tremendously.

Even though most of the people present are not participating in the global social media discussions about education, the topics of discussion were the same. This was reassuring.  There is awareness at the system level of what needs to be in place and a sincere commitment to becoming better at supporting teachers and classroom practices as we move forward.

There is:


1.  Awareness that listening is better.
2.  Awareness that voices have to be heard.
3.  Awareness that we can't be told into understanding.
4.  Awareness that conversation is the key to relationship building, insight development and willingness to move forward and develop better practices.
5. Awareness that this has been a process of trial and error and everyone has learned along the way.
6. Awareness that there have been many challenges.
7. Awareness that there has been incredible growth in practice led and developed by teachers during the
    implementation of TLCP
7. Awareness that initial attempts to bring about change and in particular, the school review process,
   were awkward.
8.  Awareness that top down doesn't work.
9. Awareness that there is a change curve and that everyone is at different points along the curve. There are the risk takers and  experimenters who are willing to give it a go and see what happens; there are also the methodical adopters who need to move slowly and carefully in order to gain understanding; and of course there are the resistors who see no need for change because what they are doing works.

Most of all there is:

8. Awareness that conversation is the key to moving forward.
9. Awareness that conversation is the key to moving forward.
10 Awareness that conversation is the key to moving forward.

Two questions arose several times during discussions.  How can we get our teachers to trust us? Why are some teachers still resistant to this process? I took the opportunity to share my insights on how I have experienced this process of change and why I think barriers are still present.  Teachers have yet to be full participants in the conversation.  The kind of  event I experienced that day is not being created for teachers, except for Edcamps which teachers are organizing themselves outside of Board practices.  Without a voice, we continue to feel that our expertise, knowledge and skills are not valued.  A sense of respect for teachers as highly skilled professionals with insights to share is still missing.  Implementation is still being experienced as top down, "Now we want you to do this."  It truly makes me wonder why, if there is awareness at the Ministry level of the importance of conversation and questions,  Open Space isn't being used as part of our professional development model.

Here's an example. On Professional Development Days the agenda is set for us. It is decided from above what the discussion topic will be, what it is we are expected to learn and what we are to produce  to prove that the discussion occurred.  Oh, the ironies!  This runs counter to everything we know about learning and to what we are expected to be doing in our classrooms. In terms of system change, this may have been necessary as the introduction of new practices requires training. What hasn't been created yet though, is space for teachers, consultants and admins to have an open and honest conversation about where we are at and to simply share our experiences and insights about this journey. We are continuing to experience change as top-down decision making that we must react to.  And so teachers remain wary of the process or disengage or worse, implement resentfully.   This is no different from what causes students to disengage in classrooms.

What if instead, at our next PD day or staff meeting teachers came with their questions and had time to discuss openly and honestly what they feel needs to be discussed in order to move forward.  Or better yet, what if a full Edcamp model happened where parents, students, community members, administrators, teachers and educational assistants came together for discussion. It would be powerful. It would be freeing.

Curious for me is why teachers aren't claiming their voices. With the whole world open and transparent because of social media, why aren't more teachers taking the initiative and sharing what they think? It's puzzling, because claiming your voice, as long as it is done thoughtfully and with the goal of adding to the conversation, is powerful practice.

If there is a sincere desire to build relationship and develop from the bottom up, then space must be created for it to happen.   We need time as a group to reflect on where we are at in this process. How we've experienced it. What questions we have. What we're struggling with. I think there also needs to be a public acknowledgement and celebration from those who have pushed us through this process. It doesn't help that the one public conversation the Premier has initiated with us is - you make too much money, we're going to cut your benefits and take away your sick days. How's that for relationship building?

What if instead the message had been something like this:

For the past 10 years our school system has undergone tremendous change.  We've asked a great deal of teachers and administrators during this process. It has been difficult, there have been challenges, we've made mistakes along the way but we've also had incredible successes. And these successes are due to the hard work of our teachers.  Teachers have been asked to implement new practices, experiment with new ideas and abandon much of what they have traditionally done in classrooms.  We've asked them to do this because research shows that these practices lead to better learning environments and greater student success. Thank you for being willing to do this. You've worked hard. We've learned a great deal because of you. The practices you are developing are becoming so highly respected that they are now being imitated around the world.  The journey is not yet over, there is still more change coming, but we wanted to let you know how much we respect you for what you have accomplished.


And one final thought, with all of this change, with all of the money that's been poured into education, with the millions spent on standardized testing and standardized outcomes, with all of the adult decision making of how students will learn, are students actually engaged and passionate about how they are learning? Perhaps it's time to ask them.




Tuesday, April 3, 2012

What Standardized Tests Don't Assess



Of all the learning goals listed below, standardized testing provides information on perhaps communication - but only in a very limited way and at a stretch technical competence.

From:

Savery, John R. (2006) "Overview of Problem-based Learning: Definitions and Distinctions," Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-based
Learning: Vol. 1: Iss. 1, Article 3.
Available at: http://docs.lib.purdue.edu/ijpbl/vol1/iss1/3


The use of PBL in undergraduate education is changing gradually (e.g., Samford University,
University of Delaware) in part because of the realization by industry and government
leaders that this information age is for real. At the Wingspread Conference (1994) leaders
from state and federal governments and experts from corporate, philanthropic, higher
education, and accreditation communities were asked for their opinions and visions of
undergraduate education and to identify some important characteristics of quality performance for college and university graduates. Their report identified as important high-level
skills in communication, computation, technological literacy, and information retrieval
that would enable individuals to gain and apply new knowledge and skills as needed. The
report also cited as important the ability to arrive at informed judgments by effectively
defining problems, gathering and evaluating information related to those problems, and
developing solutions; the ability to function in a global community; adaptability; ease with
diversity; motivation and persistence (for example being a self-starter); ethical and civil
behavior; creativity and resourcefulness; technical competence; and the ability to work
with others, especially in team settings. Lastly, the Wingspread Conference report noted
the importance of a demonstrated ability to deploy all of the previous characteristics to
address specific problems in complex, real-world settings, in which the development of
workable solutions is required. Given this set of characteristics and the apparent success
of a PBL approach at producing graduates with these characteristics one could hope for
increased support in the use of PBL in undergraduate education.

ShareThis

Creative Commons License
21 Century Classroom: The Amaryllis is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://heidisiwak.blogspot.com/.